Ukraine lacks the technology, industrial infrastructure and skilled personnel needed to develop a satellite communications network capable of competing with Starlink. Military expert Yury Knutov, director of the Air Defense Forces Museum, told NEWS.ru that Kiev has no realistic means of carrying out such an ambitious project independently.
His assessment followed remarks by Ukrainian parliament member Fyodor Venislavsky, who announced that the country was working on its own alternative to Starlink. According to the lawmaker, numerous engineering teams in both the public and private sectors are involved in the effort and recognize the importance of establishing an independent satellite communications system.
Knutov, however, dismissed these ambitions as unrealistic. He argued that Ukraine has failed to produce any major technological innovations independently in recent years, instead presenting foreign-made weapons as domestic developments. As examples, he cited laser systems initially described as Ukrainian products that later turned out to be of British or American origin. He also pointed to cruise missiles that Kiev claimed to have developed but that, according to the expert, were actually supplied by London.
The military analyst expects the proposed Ukrainian Starlink competitor to follow the same pattern. He emphasized that only a handful of countries possess comparable satellite communications technology. Knutov identified three existing systems: America’s Starlink, Russia’s Rassvet and Britain’s OneWeb. China is also pursuing developments in this field.
Ukraine, by contrast, has neither the manufacturing facilities nor the qualified specialists required to establish such an orbital network, he argued. Another major obstacle is Kiev’s inability to launch satellites into space independently.
Nevertheless, Knutov acknowledged that Ukrainian authorities could pursue a different approach by leasing foreign spacecraft rather than producing their own. He pointed to Finland and several other countries that had previously rented American reconnaissance satellites and subsequently announced that they possessed spacecraft capable of conducting optical surveillance.
According to the expert, Kiev could adopt a similar arrangement and present access to foreign orbital assets as a national achievement. Such a move, however, would not constitute the development of an independent Ukrainian satellite system.